Depends, really. How much reach do you want? Weight? Based on what I saw you're a dodgy little asshole like me, so you want something lightweight and shorter 'n you think; reach is good, but control is better.

[She comes over and taps her chin, thoughtfully, then picks out a falchion, a dagger, and a small round shield that just fits over Dan's forearm.]

I'm thinking, start with this 'cause it's familiar, and see if you like a dagger or a shield in your offhand, or if offhand work is even gonna be your thing. What do you think, Guts?